Handcrafted Confections

Our small batches of candy are handcrafted with real ingredients.

Factory-made candy can’t even come close to the quality that we are producing in our kitchen every day. When we say we make high-quality, premium candies, that means we use real ingredients and craft each and every piece by hand. We use real sugar, real butter, and real cream. Our fudge and toffee is hand poured and cut as soon as it cools to perfection. Our candies are made with real caramel and cream fillings, and our chocolate-covered confections, from pretzels to cookies are hand-dipped. There’s nothing artificial about what we do.

We Are Here for You!

Corporate Gifts
Fundraisers
Wholesales
Wedding & Party Favors
Craft Shows

Our History

Using the same candy making techniques Carol Ann taught us back in 1986.

If you have ever ordered candy from us, then you probably know Tesnie. She’s been the owner of Carol Ann’s Candies since 2014 when she decided to use her over 10 years of catering experience in Chicago and get back to her roots in Indiana. She grew up in the kitchen, and that included Carol Ann’s kitchen, where her mother worked side-by-side with Carol to create divinely delicious candies for over 20 years. She uses the same copper kettle from Carol’s kitchen today. In other words—we’re a family. And like family, we take pride in what we create together. We hope our candy makes you as happy as us.